Archives
Life after a heart attack: Issues of method
Emma Hughes
School of Public Health, La Trobe University, Bundoora VIC
Abstract
`Noncompliance', and its more recent counterparts `nonadherence' and `concordance', are used in the medical literature to describe patients' failure to follow health advice (Haynes et a1,1979). Since the 1960s medicine has had a keen interest in the problem of noncompliance. Not only does noncompliance mean that treatments will be less effective but also in the context of rising health care costs, it is seen as undermining the cost-effectiveness of clinical care. The same is true of health promotion/disease prevention programs. The extent to which noncompliance is a `problem' is demonstrated by the over 30,000+ references in the medical literature alone.
Theoretical critiques of the medical and related health promotion literature have identified that noncompliance is most often researched, explained, and attempts made to `solve' it on the basis of two assumptions (Trostle, 1988; Hughes, 1997; Donovan & Blake, 1992; Lerner, 1997). The first is the rationality of medical prescription and advice; the second consequent assumption is of patients' obligation to be equally rational in following medical prescription and advice, irrespective of the social context of their lives. Thus, noncompliance is viewed as primarily a problem of individual patients, explained in terms of irrational beliefs and behaviours that are barriers to compliance. Inherent in most research into noncompliance is a further assumption that `scientific' evidence overrides all other kinds of evidence. As patients' views are rarely seen as constituting scientific evidence, they are usually excluded from noncompliance research. When patients' views are included as the subject of research the aim is usually only to devise ways of
Such assumptions are extremely provocative for sociologists and unpacking 'noncompliance' is a compelling project. There is, to begin with, a sense of redressing injustice. Noncompliance stands out as a term that is used to categorise behaviours and people in a negative way. In addition, there is the sense that it is an issue inadequately researched as the assumptions about noncompliance confine research to a narrow focus and an equally narrow set of quantitative research methods.
References
Arber, S. (1993) 'Designing samples'. In N.
Gilbert (ed.) Researching Social Life, Sage,
London.
Bailey, K.D. (1997) 'Research methods for
creating a just world: Overcoming barriers to
inclusion in social research', Association Paper,
Society for the Study of Social Problems.
Donovan, J.L. & Blake, D.R. (1992) 'Patient noncompliance:
Deviance or reasoned decisionmaking',
Social Science and Medicine, 34: 507-13.
Glaser, B.G. & Strauss, A.L. (1967) The
Discovery of Grounded Theory, Aldine
Publishing, New York.
Haynes, R.B., Taylor, D.W. & Sackett, D.L. (eds)
(1979) Compliance in Health Care, John Hopkins,
Baltimore.
Hughes, E. (1997) 'Health promotion and
"noncompliance": An analysis of resistance to
regulatory technologies', Annual Review of Health
Social Sciences, 7: 18-24.
Layder, D. (1993) New Strategies in Social
Research, Polity Press, Cambridge.
Lerner, B.H. (1997) 'From careless consumptives
to recalcitrant patients: The historical
construction of noncompliance', Social Science
and Medicine, 45, 9: 1423-31.
Petersen, A. & Waddell, C. (eds) (1998) Health
Matters: A sociology of illness prevention and care,
Allen&Unwin, Sydney.
Roberts, M.C. & Wurtele, S.K. (1980) 'On the
noncompliant research subject in a study of
medical noncompliance', Social Science and
Medicine, 14A: 171.
Strauss, A.L. (1987) Qualitative Analysis for
Social Scientists, Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge.
Strauss, A.L. & Corbin, J. (1990) Basics of
Qualitative Research: Grounded theory procedures
and techniques, Sage, London.
Trostle, J.A. (1988) 'Medical compliance as an
ideology', Social Science and Medicine, 27, 12:
1299-1308.
Reference Appendix
Alonzo, A.A. (1997) 'Heart attacks and posttraumatic
stress disorder: The consequences of
cumulative adversity', Association Paper, Society
for the Study of Social Problems.
Agarwal, M., Dalai, A.K., Agarwal, D.K. &
Agarwal, R.K. (1995) 'Positive life orientation
and recovery from myocardial infarction', Social
Science and Medicine, 40, 1: 125-130.
Baile, W.F. & Engel, B.T. (1978) 'A behavioral
strategy for promoting treatment compliance
following myocardial infarction', Psychosomatic
Medicine, 40, 5: 413-419.
Ben-Sira, Z. & Eliezer, R. (1990) 'The structure of
readjustment after heart attack', Social Science
and Medicine, 30, 5: 523-536.
Bonaguidi, F., Michelassi, C, Trivella, M.G.,
Carpeggiani, C. & L'Abbate, A. (1997)
'Hierarchical structure of personality in patients
with acute myocardial infarction', Psychological
Reports, 81: 175-186.
Brezinka, V. & Kittel, F. (1995) 'Psychosocial
factors of coronary heart disease in women: a
review', Social Science and Medicine, 429, 10:1351-
65.
Carney, R.M., Freedland, K.E., Eisen, S.A., Rich,
M.W. & Jaffe, A.S. (1995) 'Major depression and
medication adherence in elderly patients with
coronary artery disease', Health Psychology, 14, 1:
88-90.
Case, R.B., Moss, A.J., Case, N., McDermott, M.
& Eberly, S. (1992) 'Living alone after myocardial
infarction: impact on prognosis', Journal of the
American Medical Association, 267: 515.
Chiou, A., Potempa, K. & Buschmann, M.B.
(1997) 'Anxiety, depression and coping methods
of hospitalized patients with myocardial
infarction', Taiwan International Journal of
Nursing Studies, Aug, 34, 4: 305-11.
Denollet, J., Sys, S.U. & Brutsaert, D.L. (1995)
'Personality and mortality after myocardial
infarction', Psychosomatic Medicine, 57: 582-591.
Ewart, C.K. & Fitzgerald, S.T. (1994) 'Changing
behaviour and promoting well-being after heart
attack: A social action theory approach' Irish
Journal of Psychology, 15, 1: 219-41.
Frasure-Smith, N., Lesperance, F. & Talaji, M.
(1995) 'The impact of negative emotions on
prognosis following myocardial infarction: Is it
more than depression?', Health Psychology, 14, 5:
388-98.
Frasure-Smith, N., Lesperance, F., Juneau, M.,
Talajic, M. & Bourassa, M.G. (1999) 'Gender,
depression, and one-year prognosis after
myocardial infarction', Psychosomatic Medicine,
61:26-37.
Greenwood, D.C., Muir, K.R., Packham, C.J. &
Madeley, R.J. (1995a) 'Stress, social support, and
stopping smoking after myocardial infarction in
England', Journal of Epidemiology and
Community Health, 49: 583-7.
Greenwood. D.C., Packham, C, Muir, K. &
Madeley, R. (1995b) 'How do economic status and
social support influence survival after initial
recovery from acute myocardial infarction?',
Social Science and Medicine, 40, 5: 639-47.
Horwitz, R.I., Viscoli, C.M., Berkman, L.,
Donaldson, R.M., Horwitz, S.M., Murray, C.J.,
Ransohoff, D.F. & Sindelar, J. (1990) 'Treatment
adherence and risk of death after a myocardial
infarction'. Lancet, 336: 542-5.
Ickovics, J.R., Viscoli, CM. & Horwitz, R.I.
(1997) 'Functional recovery after myocardial
infarction in men: The independent effects of
social class', Annals of Internal Medicine, 127, 7:
518-25.
Jenkinson, C.M., Madeley, R.J., Mitchell, J.R. &
Turner, I.D. (1993) 'The influence of psychosocial
factors on survival after myocardial infarction',
Public Health, 107, 5: 305-17.
Kahana, E., Young, R.F., Kercher, K. &
Kaczynski, R. (1993) 'Testing a symmetrical
model of caregiving outcomes during recovery
from heart attacks', Research on Aging; 15, 4: 371-
98.
Lesperance, F., Frasure-Smith, N. & Talajic, M.
(1996) 'Major depression before and after
myocardial infarction: Its nature and
consequences', Psychosomatic Medicine, 58, 2: 99-
110.
McSweeney, J.C. (1993) 'Making behavior
changes after a myocardial infarction', Western
Journal of Nursing research, 15, 4: 441-55.
Miller, P., Wikoff, R.L., McMahon, M., Garrett,
M.J. & Ringel, K. (1985) 'Indicators of medical
regimen adherence for myocardial infarction
patients', Nursing Research, 34: 268-72.
Rose, G.L., Suls, J., Green, P.J. & Lounsbury, P.
(1996) 'Comparison of adjustment, activity, and
tangible social support in men and women
patients and their spouses during the six months
post-myocardial infarction', Annals of Behavioral
Medicine, 8, 4:264-73.
Ruberman, W., Weinblatt, E., Goldberg, J.D. &
Chaudhary, B.S. (1984) 'Psychosocial influence on
mortality after myocardial infarction', New
England Journal of Medicine, 311: 552.
Shapiro, P.A., Lesperance, F., Frasure-Smith, N.,
O'Connor, CM., Baker, B., Jiang, J.W., Dorian, P.,
Harrison, W. & Glassman, A.H. (1999) 'An openlabel
preliminary trial of sertraline for treatment
of major depression after acute myocardial
infarction (the SADHAT Trial). Sertraline Anti-
Depressant Heart Attack Trial', American Heart
Journal, 137, 6: 1100-6.
Waltz, M. & Badura, B. (1988) 'Subjective health,
intimacy, and perceived self-efficacy after heart
attack: Predicting life quality five years
afterwards', Social Indicators Research, 20, 3: 303-
32.
eContent Home