Professionalisation, rationalisation and policy change: The transfer of pre-registration nurse education to the University sector
Elizabeth Herdman
Abstract
In 1983 the New South Wales government announced that all pre-registration nurse education would be transferred to the tertiary education sector by 1985. Prior to this, over three decades of lobbying by national and international nursing organisations on the basis of professionalisation had failed to move successive governments.
A change of strategy in 1980 saw nursing bodies argue for the transfer of nurse education on economic grounds and within three years nursing education policy was changed. This paper examines the effects of this policy change on the work experiences of practising nurses.
Using the methods of ethnography the disabling contradictions between professionalisation and rationalisation are explored to reveal how the internal politics of nursing is characterised by contestation between dominant and marginalised voices. Dominant groups cast 'nursing' and 'professionalisation' in universal terms which preserve and expand their own privilege at the expense of the majority of.practising nurses who have experienced deskilling.
References
Burbidge GN (1977) Nursing Care and Nursing Education, 2nd Annual Oration of the NSW College of Nursing. NSW College of Nursing (ed) Annual Orations 1953-76.
Chittick R (1968) Assignment Report. Manila: WHO Regional Office for the Western Pacific.
Creighton H and Lopez F (1982) A History of Nursing Education in New South Wales. Australia.
English National Board for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting (1985) Professional Education/Training Courses: Consultation Paper. London: ENB.
Forsyth S (1993) Theorising in the Sociology of the Professions: Relevance for Nursing. In Cermov J (ed) Health Papers. TASA '93. Presented at the 'Social Theory in Practice' Conference. Dec 12-15.
Game A and Pringle R (1983) Gender and Work. Sydney. Allen & Unwin.
Gillam R (1967) The Role of the Trained Nurse with Direct Patient Responsibilities in the Wards of Public Hospitals in the State of New South Wales. Vols I and II, Kensington, Sydney. University of New South Wales Press.
Gray G and Pratt R (1989) Issues in Australian Nursing 2. Melbourne. Churchill Livingstone.
Haines J (1986) Interview with the General Secretary. Nurses Reform 1(15): 2.
Herdman E (1985) ‘The Professionalisation of Nursing: Strategies and Constraints'. Unpublished Thesis, Social Science. University of New South Wales.
Herdman E (1992) ‘The Deskilling of Registered Nurses: The Social Transformation of Nursing Work in a New South Wales Hospital 1970-1990'. Unpublished PhD Thesis. Department of Sociology, the University of Wollongong.
Institute of Hospital Matrons of NSW and the ACT (1967) Report of the Committee to Consider all Aspects of Nursing. Part I. Sydney.
Institute of Hospital Matrons of NSW and the ACT (1969) Report of the Committee to Consider all Aspects of Nursing. Part II. Sydney.
International Council of Nurses (1961) Reports of Standing Committees. Melbourne, Renwick Pride Print.
International Council of Nurses (1965) An enquiry into basic nursing education, International Nursing Review 12(4): July/August.
Jayawardena Y (1985) The Nursing Workforce: Some Burning Issues, The Lamp.
Kermode S and Brown C (1995) Where have all the flowers gone? Nursing's escape from the radical critique. Contemporary Nurse 4: 8-15.
Maries F (1988) Study of Professional Issues in Nursing. Victorian Health Department.
National Survey of Nursing Personnel (1978) Report of the Committee on Nursing Personnel Survey, Vols I, II. Commonwealth Department of Health.
Nursing Organisations Representative Committee (1976) A Crisis in Nursing Education. Sydney: April.
Nurses Education Board of NSW (1980) Report of the Committee Established to Consider the Future Organisation of Nursing Education in the Sydney Metropolitan Area.
Palmer GR and Short SD (1994) Health Care and Public Policy: An Australian Analysis 2nd edn, Macmillan, South Melbourne.
Report of the National Review of Nurse Education in the Higher Education Sector - 1994 and Beyond (1994) Nursing Education in Australian Universities. AGPS. Canberra.
Royal Australian Nursing Federation and College of Nursing (1962) Submission on Nurse Education to the Australian Universities Commission on the Future of Tertiary Education in Australia. Melbourne.
Royal College of Nursing, Commission on Nursing Education (1985) The Education of Nurses: A New Dispensation (Judge Report). London: RCN.
Royal College of Nursing, Australia (1990) Nursing Targets: Education 1989-2000 Proceedings of the Nursing Education Targets Project. April 1988-March 1990, Victoria.
Sax Report (1978) Report of the Committee of Inquiry into Nurse Education and Training to the Tertiary Education Commission. Nurse Education and Training. Canberra: AGPS.
Short S and Sharman E (1987) The Nursing Struggle in Australia. Image 19(4): 197-200.
Short SD, Sharman E and Speedy S (1993) Sociology for Nurses. Macmillan: South Melbourne.
Speedy S (1987) Feminism and the Professionalisation of Nursing, The Australian Journal of Advanced Nursing 4(2): 20-28.
The Australian Nurse Teachers' Society (NSW) (1988) ‘I Have a Dream'. 3rd Annual Conference. Sydney.
Thompson JB (1984) Studies in the Theory of Ideology. Cambridge, Polity Press.
Truskett Report (1970) Report of the Committee Appointed by the Minister for Health to Inquire into the Education of Nurses. Sydney: NSW Government Printer.
Turner B (1985) Knowledge, Skill and Occupation Strategy: The Professionalisation of Paramedical Groups. Community Health Studies IX(1): 38-47.
Turner B (1986) Vocabulary of Complaints: Nursing, Professionalism and Job Context. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology 22(3): 368-386.
United Kingdom Central Council for Nursing, Midwifery and Health Visiting (1987) Project 2000: The Final Proposals. Project Paper 9, UKCC, London.
World Health Organisation (1966) Expert Committee on Nursing Fifth Report. WHO Technical Report Series. No 347, Geneva.
Willis E (1989) Medical Dominance. Sydney, Allen & Unwin.
eContent Home
