Family Law as a determinant of child health and welfare: Shared parenting, breastfeeding and the best interests of the child
Linda Sweet
Onkaparinga Clinical Education Program (OCEP); Clinical Education, Rural Clinical School, School of Medicine, Flinders University, Adelaide SA
Charmaine Power
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Flinders University, Adelaide SA
PP: 108 - 118
Abstract
Breastfeeding is the optimal nutrition for infants and requires the infant and mother to spend significant time together. In July 2006 the Australian Government introduced the Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Act 2006 (Cth) (the Shared Parental Responsibility Act 2006) which puts in place a legal presumption of shared parental responsibility for children after separation and which emphasises 'equal time' parenting arrangements.
The expectation of 'equal time' or substantial and significant parenting arrangements becomes problematic when considering breastfed children. Decisions about parenting of children under the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) are required to be made with the 'best interests of the child' as the paramount consideration; a central tenet of the Act which remains in place following the Shared Parental Responsibility Act 2006. There appears to be a tension in determining the best interests of the child in cases where children are breastfed and their father is seeking equal or substantial shared care arrangements.
This article begins a discussion about the decisions regarding 'shared parenting' of breastfed children that do not always appear to be in the best interests of children's health and well-being. Two cases from an on-going study to investigate breastfeeding women's experiences of the implementation of the Act will be used to illustrate that the court made decisions for breastfeeding mothers are not consistent and compromise the ability of women to continue breast feeding.
The paper argues that the Shared Parental Responsibility Act 2006, and the decisions made, can work at a macro-level to produce social and health disparities for these children. Further questions are raised about the best interests of children when domestic violence and/or abuse are present. The impact of this new law on the continued breastfeeding of very young children is an unacknowledged consequence and a public health concern.
Keywords
sociology, Family Law, breastfeeding, best interests of the child
References
Akre J (1989) Infant Feeding The Physiological Basis, World Health Organisation: Geneva.
Akre J (2006) The Problem with Breastfeeding: A Personal Reflection, Hale Publishing: Texas.
Atmore C, Budavari R, Fletcher J, Finn K and Kelly A (2005) Seeing Families Right, National Association of Community Legal Services: Sydney.
Australian Institute of Family Studies (2007) Growing up in Australia: The Longitudinal Study of Australian Children 2006-07 Annual Report, Australian Institute of Family Studies: Melbourne.
Bailey C (2007) Inquiry into Breastfeeding, House of Representatives Standing Committee on Health and Aging: Canberra.
Bar-Yam N.B (2003) Breastfeeding and human rights: Is there a right to be breastfed? Journal of Human Lactation 19(4): 357-361.
Baum F (2008) The New Public Health, Oxford University Press: South Melbourne.
Baum F and Harris L (2006) Equity and the social determinants of health, Health Promotion Journal of Australia 17(3): 163-165.
Biringen Z, Greve-Spees J, Howard W, Leith D, Tanner L, Moore S, Sakoguchi S and Williams L (2002) Commentary on Warshak's 'Blanket restrictions: Overnight contact between parents and young children', Family Court Review 40(2): 204-207.
Blane D (2006) The life course, the social gradient, and health, in Marmot M and Wilkinson R (eds) Social Determinants of Health 2nd edn, Oxford University Press: New York, pp.54-77.
Braaf R and Sneddon C (2007) Family Law Act Reform: The potential for screening and risk assessment for family violence, Australian Domestic and Family Violence Clearinghouse, Issues Paper 12.
Brodribb W (2004) Breastfeeding Management, Australian Breastfeeding Association: East Malvern.
Chisholm R (2006) The Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Bill 2006: Putting Children at Centre Stage? Contact and Relocation - Focusing on Children, Centre for Children and Young People, Southern Cross University: Byron Bay.
Family Court of Australia (2004) Tackling the Scourge of Family Violence, Family Court of Australia: Canberra.
Fehlberg B, Behrens J and Kaspiew R (2008) Australian Family Law: The Contemporary Context, Oxford University Press: South Melbourne.
Gribble K (2006) Mental health, attachment and breastfeeding: Implications for adopted children and their mothers, International Breastfeeding Journal 1(1): 5.
House of Representatives (2007) The Best Start: Report on the Inquiry into the Health Benefits of Breastfeeding, Standing Committee on Health and Ageing, Commonwealth of Australia: Canberra.
Hume M (2008) No Escape from Violence: The Silencing of Women and Children, Shared Parental Responsibility in Australian Family Law and the Impact on Children, Centre for Peace, Conflict and Mediation, University of South Australia: Adelaide.
Kent G (2004) Letters to the editor: Response to 'Breastfeeding and human rights', Journal of Human Lactation 20(2): 146-147.
Labbok M (2001) Effects of breastfeeding on the mother, Pediatric Clinics of North America 48(1): 143-158.
Labbok M (2006) Breastfeeding: A woman's reproductive right, International Journal of Gynecology and Obstetrics 94: 277-286.
Lawrence RA and Lawrence R (2005) Breastfeeding: A Guide for the Medical Profession, Mosby: St Louis MO.
Marmot M and Wilkinson R (2006) Social Determinants of Health, Oxford University Press: New York.
McIntosh J (2006) Assessing attachment needs and potential in high risk infants, Journal of Family Studies 12(1): 57-71.
McIntosh J and Chisholm R (2007) Shared care and children's best interests in conflicted separation: A cautionary tale from current research, Australian Family Lawyer 20(1): 1-11.
McIntosh J and Chisholm R (2008) Cautionary notes on the shared care of children in conflicted parental separation, Journal of Family Studies 14(1): 37-52.
Miller G (2002) The psychological best interest of the child is not the legal best interest, The Journal of the American Academy of Psychiatry and the Law 30(2): 196-200.
Minchin M (1987) Infant formula: A mass, uncontrolled trial in perinatal care, BIRTH 14(1): 25-35.
Montgomery SM, Ehlin A and Sacker A (2006) Breast feeding and resilience against psychosocial stress, Archives of Disease in Childhood 91: 990-994.
National Council of Single Mothers and Their Children (2007) Inquiry into Breastfeeding, House of Representatives Standing Committee on Health and Aging: Canberra.
NHMRC (2003a) Dietary Guidelines for Adult Australians: A Guide to Healthy Eating, National Health and Medical Research Council and Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing: Canberra.
NHMRC (2003b) Dietary Guidelines for Children and Adolescents in Australian Incorporating the Infant Feeding Guidelines for Health Workers, National Health and Medical Research Council and Commonwealth Department of Health and Ageing: Canberra.
Office of the United Nations Commissioner for Human Rights (1948) Universal Declaration of Human Rights, United Nations: Geneva.
Palmer G (1988) The Politics of Breastfeeding, Pandora Press: London.
Parkinson P and Behrens J (2004) Australian Family Law in Context: Commentary and Materials, Lawbook Co: Pyrmont NSW.
Riordan JM (1997) The cost of not breastfeeding: A commentary, Journal of Human Lactation 13(2): 93-97.
Schofield T (2007) Health inequity and its social determinants: A sociological commentary, Health Sociology Review 16(2): 105-114.
Smyth B (2004) Parent-Child Contact and Post- Separation Parenting Arrangements, Australian Institute of Family Studies: Melbourne.
Wilkinson R and Marmot M (2003) Social Determinants of Health: The Solid Facts, World Health Organisation: Geneva.
World Health Organisation (1989) Protecting, Promoting and Supporting Breastfeeding: The Special Role of Maternity Units. A Joint WHO/UNICEF Statement, World Health Organisation: Geneva.
eContent Home
