Archives
Global challenges, global solutions?: A cross-national comparison of primary health care in Britain, Norway and the Czech Republic
Olaug S Lian
Department of Community Medicine, University of Tromsř, Norway
Abstract
Are current health policy changes leading to a greater degree of convergence in the health systems of European nations, or to a pattern of divergence? How can the degree of convergence / divergence be explained, and what can it tell us about local versus global impulses of change?
The most common answer to these questions is that because the process of globalisation is driving different countries toward similar reform programs, their health systems converge at some common point. An alternative hypothesis is that each country has unique cultural, economic, political and historical traditions which are likely to override global changes, thus creating patterns of divergence.
In this article, theories of globalisation and convergence are the theoretical foundation for a cross-national comparison of the development of primary health care in Europe. By comparing the development in three different countries between 1990 and 2005, converging and diverging paths are identified and explained.
Keywords
primary health care, health policy, comparative sociology, globalisation, convergence, Europe
References
Anonymous (1997) Four Country Conference 1997 On Primary Health Care. Gesellschaft für versicherungswissen-schaft und-gestaltung ev: Köln.
Boerma W, Van Der Zee J and Fleming D (1997) Service profiles of general practitioners in Europe. British Journal of General Practice 47: 481–486.
Bradshaw Y and Wallace M (2006) Informing generality and explaining uniqueness: The place of case studies in comparative research, in Sica A (ed) Comparative Methods In The Social Sciences. Sage: London, pp.241–259.
Brunsson N and Olsen J (1993) The Reforming Organization. Routledge: London.
Chernichovsky D (1995) Health system reforms in industrialized democracies: An emerging paradigm. Milbank Quartely 73: 339–372.
Cohen A (1985) The Symbolic Construction of Community. Routledge: London.
Department of Health and Social Affairs (2000) Regulation Relating to a Municipal Regular GP Scheme. Department of Health and Social Affairs: Oslo.
Department of Health (2001) Milburn Hands Power to Front-Line Staff. HMSO: London.
Department of Health (2005) Statistics for General Medical Practitioners in England: 1994–2004. HMSO: London.
Form W (1979) Comparative industrial sociology and the convergence hypothesis. Annual Review of Sociology 5: 1–25.
Förster M and d’Ercole M (2005) Income Distribution and Poverty in OECD Countries in the Second Half of the 1990s. OECD: Paris.
Freeman R (2000) The Politics of Health in Europe. Manchester University Press: Manchester.
Friedman J (2003) The paradoxes of ‘real-existing’ globalization. Elite discourses and the grassroots, in Thuen T (ed) Sted og Tilhørighet Høyskoleforlaget: Kristiansand, pp.223–245.
Global Health Watch (2005) An Alternative World Health Report. Accessed at http://www.ghwatch.org/2005_report.php on 22 May 2008.
Gravelle H and Sutton M (1998) Trends in geographical inequalities in provision of general practitioners in England and Wales. The Lancet 352: 1910.
Harris R and Seid M (2004) Globalization and health in the new millennium, in Harris R and Seid M (eds) Globalization and Health. Brill: Leiden, pp.1–46.
Hawkes N (2006) NHS reorganisation. Who’s kicking who? British Medical Journal 333: 645–648.
Hnilicová H (2002) Czech Republic, in Fried B and Gaydos L (eds) World Health Systems. Challenges and Perspectives. Administration Press: Chicago, pp.311–327.
Hoffman L (2000) Czech physicians and health care reform in comparative perspective, in Křižová E and Šimek J (eds) Health Care Reforms in Central and Eastern Europe: Outcomes and Challenges. Charles University and School of Public Health: Praha, pp.43–57.
Holčik J and Koupilová I (2000) Primary health care in the Czech Republic: Brief history and current issues. International Journal of Integrated Care 1: 1–10.
Hood C (1998) The Art of the State. Culture, Rhetoric, and Public Management. Clarendon Press: Oxford.
Hood C (1994) Explaining Economic Policy Reversal. Open University Press: Buckingham.
Hudson B (1999) Decentralisation and primary care groups: A paradigm shift for the National Health Service in England? Policy and Politics 27: 159–172.
Immergut E (1992) Health Politics. Interests and Institutions in Western Europe. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge.
Inglehart R (2006) Mapping global values. Comparative Sociology 5: 115–136.
Inkeles A (1981) Convergence and divergence in industrial societies, in Attir M, Holzner B and Suda Z (eds) Directions of Change. Modernization Theory, Research, and Realities. Westview: Boulder CO, pp.3–38.
Jacobs A (1998) Seeing difference: Market health reform in Europe. Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law 23: 1–34.
Jaroš J and Kalina K (1999) Czech Health Care System. Delivery and Financing. OECD Study Czech Association For Health Services Research: Praha.
Jaroš J, Kalina K, Dlouhy M and Malina A (2003) Decentralisation and Governance in Health Care Service Provision in the Czech Republic in the 1990s. Czech Association for Health Services Research: Praha.
Klein R (2001) The New Politics of the NHS. Prentice Hall: London.
Kohn M (1989) Cross-national research as an analytic strategy, in Kohn M (ed) Cross-National Research in Sociology. Sage: Newbury Park CA, pp.77–102.
Křižová E (2000) The Czech health care system transformation at the cross-roads, in Křižová E and Šimek J (eds) Health Care Reforms In Central And Eastern Europe: Outcomes And Challenges. Charles University and School of Public Health: Praha, pp.85–92.
Marrée J and Groenewegen P (1997) Back to Bismarck: Eastern European Health Care Systems in Transition. Avebury: Aldershot.
Mason D and Kluegel J (2000) Introduction: Public opinion and political change in the postcommunist states, in Mason D and Kluegel J (eds) Marketing Democracy. Changing Opinion About Inequality and Politics in East Central Europe. Rowman & Littlefield: Oxford, pp.1–25.
Mechanic D and Rochefort D (1996) Comparative medical systems. Annual Review of Sociology 22: 239–270.
Navarro V (2001) Review of 'Exploring health policy development in Europe'. International Journal of Health Services 31: 869–874.
Norwegian Research Council (2006) Evaluering av fastlegereformen 2001-2005. Norwegian Research Council: Oslo.
OECD (1994) In the Reform of Health Care Systems: A Review of Seventeen OECD Countries. OECD: Paris.
OECD (2005) OECD Economic Surveys Norway. OECD: Paris.
OECD (2007a) OECD Health Data 2007. OECD: Paris.
OECD (2007b) OECD in Figures 2007. OECD: Paris.
Peckham S and Exworthy M (2003) Primary Care in the UK. Policy, Organisation and Management. Palgrave Macmillan: New York.
Phare (1997) Development of Primary Care in the Czech Republic: Final Report. Phare: Praha.
Pollitt C (2000) Is the emperor in his underwear? An analysis of the impacts of public management reform. Public Management 2: 181–199.
Pollitt C and Summa H (1997) Trajectories of reform: Public management change in four countries. Public Money and Management 17: 7–18.
Powell F (1999) Patterns of health care system change, in Powell F and Wessen A (eds) Health Care Systems in Transition: An International Perspective. Sage: Thousand Oaks, pp.393–413.
Rathwell T, Godinho J and Gott M (1995) Tipping the Balance Towards Primary Health Care Avebury: Aldershot.
Renade W (ed) (1998) Markets and Health Care: A Comparative Analysis. Longman: London.
Riksrevisjonen (2005) Riksrevisjonens Undersøkelse Om Forvaltning Av Og Måloppnåelse i Fastlegeordningen, accessed at http://www.riksrevisjonen.no on 22 May 2008.
Rikstrygdeverket (2007) Styringsdata For Fastlegeordningen, accessed at http://www.nav.no/binary/805364343/file on 22 May 2008.
Ritzer G (2004) The Globalization Of Nothing. Pine Forge Press: Thousand Oaks.
Roland M (2004) Linking physicians’ pay to the quality of care: A major experiment in the United Kingdom. New England Journal of Medicine 351: 1448–1454.
Short S, Toneva Z and Hadjiev V (2007) On the inequitable impact of universal health insurance: The experience of Bulgaria in transition. Health Sociology Review 16: 130–145.
Smith J and Barnes M (2000) Developing primary care groups in the new NHS: Towards diversity or uniformity? Public Money and Management 20: 45–52.
Tuohy C (1999) Accidental Logics. The Dynamics of Change in the Health Care Arena in the United States, Britain, and Canada. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Vlachová K and Večernik J (1999) The role of the market and government in the eyes of the public, in Večernik J and Matějů P (eds) Ten Years of Rebuilding Capitalism: Czech Society After 1989. Academia: Praha, pp.183–203.
Waters M (2001) Globalization. Routledge: London.
Wessen A (1999a) Structural differences and health care reform, in Powell F and Wessen A (eds) Health Care Systems in Transition. An International Perspective. Sage: Thousand Oaks, pp.369–392.
Wessen A (1999b) The comparative study of health care reform, in Powell F and Wessen A (eds) Health Care Systems in Transition. An International Perspective. Sage: Thousand Oaks, pp.3-24.
WHO (2005) Health Care Systems In Transition: Czech Republic. European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies 7(1). Accessed at www.euro.who.int/Document/E86823.pdf on 22 May 2008.
WHO (2007) European Health For All. Accessed at http://www.euro.who.int/hfadb on 22 May 2008.
Zdravotnická statistika ČR (2004a) Health Care and Health Services in the Czech Republic 2003. Zdravotnická statistika ČR: Praha.
Zdravotnická statistika ČR (2004b) Economic Information on Health Care 2003. Zdravotnická statistika ČR: Praha.
eContent Home
