Archives
The Mismanagement of Dying
Beverley McNamara
Senior Lecturer Anthropology and Sociology, School of Social and Cultural Studies, The University of Western Australia
Lorna Rosenwax
Head, School of Occupational Therapy
Curtin University of Technology
Abstract
This paper reports on a recent population-based study of the last months of life of 1071 people in Western Australia who died from a chronic condition. Data was collected from death certificates and telephone interviews of primary carers who acted as proxies providing second hand accounts of the severity of the deceased person's symptoms and sources of concerns, their awareness and acceptance of dying, and experiences of the health care system.
We present descriptive statistics and quotes supporting our premise that dying in Australia is largely mismanaged. We base our assertions on three themes: dying with multiple conditions and symptoms; awareness and acceptance of dying; and support during the dying process.
Each theme illustrates the difficulty of self-managing complex conditions, the failure of the health care system to acknowledge this complexity, and the need for a more radical and social approach to the management of dying.
Keywords
dying, cancer, awareness of death, good death, end of life, sociology
References
Addington-Hall J, Walker L, Jones C, Karlsen S and McCarthy M. (1998) A randomised controlled trial of postal versus interviewer administration of a questionnaire measuring satisfaction with, and use of, services received in the year before death. Journal of Epidemiology Community Health 52(12):802-807.
Addington-Hall J and Higginson I (2001) Palliative Care for Non-cancer Patients. Oxford University Press: Oxford.
Australian Bureau of Statistics (2005) Causes of Death, Australia 2005. ABS available at http://www.abs.gov.au/ausstats/abs@.nsf/0/2093DA6935DB138FCA2568A9001393C9
Barbato M (2002) Caring for the Dying. McGraw Hill Book Company: Sydney.
Beckstrand R, Clark Callister L and Kirchhoff K (2006) Providing a 'good death': Critical care nurses' suggestions for improving end of life care. American Journal of Critical Care 15(1):38-42.
Chibnall J, Videen S, Duckro P and Miller D (2002) Psychosocial-spiritual correlates of death distress in patients with life-threatening medical conditions. Palliative Medicine 16:331-338.
Clark D and Seymour J (1999) Reflections on Palliative Care: Sociological and Policy Perspectives. Open University Press: Buckingham, UK.
Field D (1996) Awareness and modern dying. Mortality 1(3):255-265.
Fordham S and Dowrick C (1999) Is care of the dying improving? The contribution of specialist and non-specialist palliative care. Journal of Family Practice 16(6):573-579.
Glaser B and Strauss A (1966) Awareness of Dying. Weidenfeld and Nicholson: London.
Giddens A (1991) Modernity and Self-identity: Self and Society in the Late Modern Age. Stanford University Press: Stanford, CA.
Good M, Good B, Schaffer C and Lind S (1990) American oncology and the discourse of hope. Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry 14(1):59-79.
Hinton J (1996) How reliable are relatives' retrospective reports of terminal illness? Patients' and relatives' accounts compared. Social Science and Medicine 43(8):1229-1236.
Hoyert DL (1996) Mortality trends for Alzheimer's disease: 1979-1991. Vital Health Statistics 28:1-23.
Hughes K (2004) Health as individual responsibility: Possibilities and personal struggle. In Tovey, P, Easthope G and Adams J (eds) The Mainstreaming of Complementary and Alternative Medicine: Studies in Social Context. Routledge: London and New York.
Jordens C, Little M, Kerridge I and McPhee J (2005) From advance directives to advance care planning: Current legal status, ethical rationales and a new research agenda. Internal Medicine Journal 35(9):563-566.
Kapo J, Harrold J, Carroll JT, Rickerson E and Casarett D (2005) Are we referring patients to hospice too late: Patients and families' opinions. Journal of Palliative Medicine 8(3):521-527.
Kellehear A (2007) A Social History of Dying. Cambridge University Press: Cambridge, UK.
Kellehear A (1990) Dying of Cancer: The Final Year of Life. Harwood: London.
Lawton J (2000) The Dying Process: Patients' Experiences of Palliative Care. Routledge: London.
Logue B (1994) When hospice fails: The limits of palliative care. Omega 29(4): 291-301.
Lugton J (2003) Communicating with Dying People and Their Relatives. Ausmed: Melbourne.
Mannino DM, Brown C and Giovino GA (1997) Obstructive lung disease deaths in the United States from 1979 through 1993. An analysis using multiple-cause mortality data. American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine 156(3 Pt 1):814-8.
McNamara B and Rosenwax L (2007) Factors affecting place of death in Western Australia. Health and Place 13(2):356-367.
McNamara B, Rosenwax L and Holman CDJ (2006) A method for defining and estimating the palliative care population. Journal of Pain and Symptom Management 32:5-12.
McNamara B (2004) 'Good enough' death: Autonomy and choice in Australian palliative care. Social Science and Medicine 58(5):929-938.
McNamara B (2001) Fragile Lives: Death, Dying and Care. Allen and Unwin: Sydney.
McNamara B, Waddell C and Colvin M (1994) The institutionalisation of the good death. Social Science and Medicine 39(11):1501-1508.
Petersen A and Lupton D (1996) The New Public Health: Health and Self in the Age of Risk. Sage: London.
Rosenwax L and McNamara B (2006) Who receives specialist palliative care in Western Australia and who misses out. Palliative Medicine 20:439-445.
Rosenwax L, McNamara B, Blackmore A and Holman CDJ (2005) Estimating the size of a potential palliative care population. Palliative Medicine 19:556-562.
Sandman L (2005) A Good Death: On the Value of Death and Dying. Open University Press: Berkshire, UK.
Seale C and Cartwright A (1984) The Year Before Death. Avery: Aldershot.
Seymour J, Gott M, Bellamy G, Ahmedzai SH and Clark D (2004) Planning for the end of life: The views of older people about advance care statements. Social Science and Medicine 59(1):57-68.
Survey Research Centre, The University of Western Australia (2006) Computer Assisted Telephone Interviewing Facility (Survey Craft CATI System). Available from: http://www.publichealth.uwa.edu.au/welcome/consulting/src.
Thomsen O, Wulff H, Martin A and Singer P (1993) What do gastroenterologists in Europe tell cancer patients? Lancet 341(8843):773-776.
Walker C (2003) Putting 'self' back into self management. In Walker C, Peterson C, Millen N and Martin C (eds) Chronic Illness: New Perspectives and New Directions. Tertiary Press: Croyden, Victoria, pp.53-66.
Walters G (2004) Is there such a thing as a good death? Palliative Medicine 18:404-408.
World Health Organisation (1990) Cancer Pain Relief and Palliative Care. Report of a WHO Expert Committee Technical Report Series No 804, WHO Press: Geneva.
Zimmermann C (2007) Death denial: Obstacle or instrument for palliative care? An analysis of clinical literature. Sociology of Health & Illness 29(2):297-314.
eContent Home