Archives
Is social capital good for everyone?
The case of same-sex attracted women in rural South Australian communities
Brian Cheers
Associate Professor; Director, Centre for Rural and Regional Development, University of South Australia - Whyalla Campus, SA.
Jane Edwards
Centre for Regulation and Market Analysis, University of South Australia, South Australia
Abstract
Social capital is attracting increasing attention, particularly as a means of improving health status. However, much of the work on social capital employs Putnam's (1995) formulation of the concept. This view suggests social capital produces generalised benefits, thus presenting an anomaly between the higher stocks of social capital in Australian rural communities relative to urban areas, and their poorer health status. This paper presents data on the experience of same-sex attracted (SSA) women living in rural communities in South Australia. It suggests Bourdieu's account of social capital is more theoretically and empirically compelling than that of Putnam's, because of its capacity to explain the harmful psycho-social consequences of exclusion for those who are same-sex attracted. Moreover, the different experiences of younger and older same-sex attracted people in rural Australia indicates the need to take seriously the claim that social capital is unequally distributed and experienced in different ways. A conclusion of this paper is that blanket claims to increase and enhance social capital should be treated cautiously because of the adverse consequences for some groups.
Keywords
sociology, sexuality, rural health, social capital
References
Baum, F. (2002) The New Public Health (2nd ed) Oxford: Melbourne.
Berkman, L. (2000) ‘Social support, social networks, social cohesion and health' Social Work in Health Care 31(2):3-14.
Boudieu, P. (1993) Sociology in Question Sage: London.
Bringaze, T. and White, L. (2001) ‘Living out proud: Factors contributing to healthy identity development in lesbian leaders' Journal of Mental Health Counseling 23(2):162-173.
Cantor, C. and Neulinger, K. (2000) ‘The epidemiology of suicide and attempted suicide among young Australians' Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 34:370-387.
Cattell, V. (2001) ‘Poor people, poor places, and poor health: The mediating role of social networks and social capital' Social Science and Medicine 52(10):1501-1516.
Caughy, M.; O'Campo, P. and Muntaner, C. (2003) ‘When being alone might be better: Neighborhood poverty, social capital, and child health' Social Science and Medicine 57:227-237.
Coleman, J. (1988) ‘Social capital in the creation of human capital' American Journal of Sociology 94: Supplement S95-S120.
Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care (1999) Accessibility/Remoteness Index of Australia (ARIA), Occasional Papers Series No. 6, Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care: Canberra.
Cox, E. and Caldwell, P. (2000) ‘Making policy social' in Winter, I. (ed) Social Capital And Public Policy In Australia Australian Institute of Family Studies: Melbourne, pp. 43-73.
Dade-Smith, J. (2004) Australia's Rural and Regional Health: A Social Justice Perspective Tertiary Press: Croydon.
D'Augelli, A. (1988). ‘Lesbian women in a rural helping network: Exploring informal helping resources' Women and Therapy 8:119-130.
Dempsey, K. (1993) Smalltown: A Study Of Social Inequality, Cohesion And Belonging 2nd edition, Oxford University Press: Melbourne.
Fuller, J.; Edwards, J.; Procter, N. and Moss, J. (2000) ‘How definition of mental health problems can influence help seeking in rural and remote communities' Australian Journal of Rural Health 8:148-153.
Hawe, P. and Shiell, A. (2000) ‘Social capital and health promotion: A review' Social Science and Medicine 51(6):871-885.
Hillier, L.; Warr, D. and Haste, B. (1996) The Rural Mural: Sexuality And Diversity In Rural Youth National Centre in HIV Social Research, Faculty of Health Sciences, La Trobe University: Victoria.
Hillier, L.; Dempsey, D.; Harrison, L.; Beale, L.; Matthews, L. and Rosenthal, D. (1998/2002) Writing Themselves In: A National Report On The Sexuality, Health And Well-Being Of Same-Sex Attracted Young People Vichealth: Melbourne.
Howard, J.; Nicholas, J.; Brown, N. and Karaca, A. (2002) ‘Same-sex attracted youth and suicide' in Rowling, L.; Martin, G. and Walker, L. (eds) Mental Health Promotion And Young People: Concepts And Practice McGraw Hill: Sydney.
Hughes, P.; Bellamy, J. and Black, A. (2000) ‘Building social trust through education' in Winter, I. (ed) Social Capital And Public Policy In Australia Australian Institute of Family Studies: Melbourne, pp. 225-249.
Kawichi, I. and Berkman, L. (2000) ‘Social cohesion, social capital and health' in Kawichi Ichiro, I. and Berkman, L. (eds) Social Epidemiology Oxford University Press: New York, pp.3-13.
Liamputtong, P. and Ezzy, D. (2005) Qualitative Research Methods Oxford University Press: South Melbourne.
Macinko, J. and Starfield, B. (2001) ‘The utility of social capital in research on health determinants' The Milbank Quarterly 79(3):387-427.
Onyx, J. and Bullen, P. (2000) ‘Sources of social capital' in Winter, I. (ed) Social Capital And Public Policy in Australia Australian Institute of Family Studies: Melbourne, pp.105-135.
Oswald, R. (2002) ‘Who am I in relation to them? Gay, lesbian and queer people leave the city to attend rural family weddings' Journal of Family Issues 23:323-348.
Phillips, A. (2002) ‘Health status and utilisation of health services in rural Australia: A comparison with urban status and utilisation national databases' in Wilkinson, D. and Blue, I. (eds) The New Rural Health Oxford University Press: South Melbourne, pp. 44-57.
Portes, A. (1998) ‘Social capital: Its origins and applications in modern sociology' Annual Review Of Sociology 24:1-24.
Putnam, R. (1995) ‘Bowling alone: America's declining social capital' Journal of Democracy 6(1):65-78.
Putnam, R. (2000) Bowling Alone: The Collapse And Revival Of American Community Simon and Schuster: New York.
Putnam, R. (2001) ‘Robert Putnam on Community'
http://www.abc.net/rn/talks/1m/stories/s422145.htm (accessed May 19th 2003).
Veenstra, G. (2000) ‘Social capital, SES and health: An individual-level analysis' Social Science and Medicine 50:619-629.
Wainer, J. and Chesters, J. (2000) ‘Rural mental health: Neither romanticism nor despair' Australian Journal of Rural Health 8:141-147.
eContent Home