Archives
Emerging From the Shadow of Medicine
Allied health as a 'profession community' subculture
Rosalie Boyce
School of Management, University of Queensland,
St Lucia, Queensland
Abstract
The authority relationship between medicine and the allied health professions has been conceptualised as one of subordination. The research that underpinned the subordination thesis was largely based on pre-1980 studies of inter-professional interaction and struggle.
This article presents data from a comparative longitudinal case study analysis of Australian allied health professions employed in three distinct organisational models in urban acute care general hospitals during the 1990s. The article discusses the emergence of a distinct allied health 'profession community' subculture associated with the emergence of new organisational structures in Australia. A model to account for subculture development under different organisational conditions is proposed. A key concern is the way in which a 'profession community' is created, structured and maintained in the complex organisational settings of the acute-care hospital.
The findings challenge the notion that subordination is an inevitable consequence of medical dominance and calls for a re-formulation of our understanding of the relationship between medicine and allied health professions in light of contemporary health service reforms.
Keywords
sociology of professions, allied health professions, medical dominance, subculture, hospital structure, organisational restructuring
References
Abernethy MA and Stoelwinder JU (1995) The role of professional control in the management of complex organisations. Accounting, Organizations and Society 20:1-17.
Australian Health Workforce Advisory Committee (AHWAC) (2004) The Australian Allied Health Workforce: An Overview of Workforce Planning Issues. Sydney: AHWAC.
Begun JW and Lippincott RC (1993) Strategic Adaption in the Health Professions: Meeting the Challenges of Change. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Bloor G and Dawson P (1994) Understanding professional culture in organization context. Organization Studies 15:275-295.
Boyce RA (1991) Hospital restructuring - the implications for allied health professions. Australian Health Review 14:147-154.
Boyce RA (1993a) The Organisational Design of Hospitals - A Critical Review: A Report on the 1992 Australian College of Health Service Executives Overseas Study Award (College Monograph No 1) North Ryde, NSW: Australian College of Health Service Executives.
Boyce RA (1993b) Internal market reforms of health care systems and the allied health professions: An international perspective. International Journal of Health Planning and Management 8:201-217.
Boyce RA (1996) The Organisation of Allied Health Professions in Australian General Hospitals. Unpublished PhD thesis, Brisbane: Queensland University of Technology.
Boyce RA (1997) Health sector reform and profession power, autonomy and culture. In K Soothill, R Hugman and M Peelo (eds) Concepts of Care, London: Edward Arnold, pp.74-98.
Boyce RA (2001) Organisational governance systems in allied health services: A decade of change. Australian Health Review 24(1):22-36.
Boyce RA (2004) The allied health professions in transition. In M Clinton (ed) Management in the Australian Health Care Industry 3rd edn, Frenchs Forest: Pearson Education Australia, pp.164-187.
Boyce RA (2005) Direct access physiotherapy in Australia. Physiotherapy 9:61-2.
Boyce RA (2006) Using organisation as a strategic resource to build identity and influence. In R Jones and F Jenkins (eds) Leadership, Management & Development for Allied Health Professionals, Oxford: Radcliffe Publishing.
Braithwaite J (1993) Strategic management and organisational structure: Transformational processes at work in hospitals. Australian Health Review 16:383-404.
Braithwaite J and Westbrook M (2005) Rethinking clinical organisational structures: an attitude survey of doctors, nurses and allied health staff in clinical directorates. Journal of Health Services Research & Policy 10(1):10-17.
Carmel S (2006) Boundaries obscured and boundaries reinforced: incorporation as a strategy of occupational enhancement for intensive care. Sociology of Health and Illness 28(2):154-177.
Coburn D and Willis E (2000) The medical profession: power, knowledge and autonomy. In G Albrecht, R Fitzpatrick and S Scrimshaw (eds) Handbook of Social Studies in Health and Medicine. London: Sage, pp.377-93.
Dent M (1993) Professionalism, educated labour and the state: hospital medicine and the new managerialism. Sociological Review 41:244-273.
Degeling P, Kennedy J and Hill M (2001) Mediating the cultural boundaries between medicine, nursing and management-the central challenge in hospital reform. Health Services Management Research 14:36-48.
Degeling P, Sage D, Kennedy J, Perkins R and Zhang K (1999) A comparison of the impact of hospital reform on medical subcultures in some Australian and New Zealand hospitals. Australian Health Review 22(4):172-188.
Duckett SJ, Scarf CG, Schmiede AM and Weaver CJ (1981) The Organisation of Medical Staff in Australian Hospitals. Melbourne: Longman Cheshire.
Flynn R (1992) Medical autonomy and managerial encroachment. In R Flynn (ed) Structures of Control in Health Management. London: Routledge, pp.23-54.
Fournier V (2000) Boundary work and (un)making of the professions. In Malin N (ed) Professionalism, Boundaries and the Workplace. London: Routledge, pp.67-86.
Freidson E (1970a) Profession of Medicine: A Study of the Sociology of Applied Knowledge. New York: Dodd, Mead & Company.
Freidson E (1970b) Professional Dominance: The Social Structure of Medical Care. Aldine: Chicago.
Freidson E (1986) Professional Powers: A Study of Institutionalization of Formal Knowledge. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Freidson E (1989) Medical Work in America: Essays on Health Care. New Haven: Yale University Press.
Galley P (1977) Physiotherapists as first-contact practitioners - New challenges and responsibilities in Australia. Physiotherapy 63:246-248.
Globerman J, White J and McDonald G (2002) Social work in restructuring hospitals: program management five years later. Health & Social Work, 27(4):274-284.
Hafferty FW and McKinlay JB (1993) The Changing Medical Profession. New York: Oxford University Press.
Harrison S and Pollitt C (1994) Controlling Health Professionals: The Future of Work and Organization in the National Health Service. Buckingham: Open University Press.
Holdsworth LK and Webster VS (2004) Direct access to physiotherapy in primary care: now? - and into the future? Physiotherapy 90(2):64-72.
Kenny D and Adamson B (1992) Medicine and the health professions: Issues of dominance, autonomy and authority. Australian Health Review 15:319-334.
Kenny A and Duckett S (2004) A question of place: medical power in rural Australia. Social Science & Medicine 58(6):1059-1073.
Larkin GV (1983) Occupational Monopoly and Modern Medicine, London: Tavistock.
Larkin GV (1988) Medical dominance in Britain: Image and historical reality. Milbank Quarterly 66 (supplement 2):117-132.
Lewin K (1951) Field Theory in Social Science. New York: Harper & Row.
Light DW (2000) The medical profession and organizational change: From professional dominance to countervailing power. In CE Bird, P Conrad and AM Freemont (eds) Handbook of Medical Sociology, Upper Saddle River NJ, Prentice Hall.
McKinlay JB and Marceau LD (2002) The end of the golden age of doctoring. International Journal of Health Services 32(2):379-416.
O'Kane A and Lowe S (2003) Clinical Allied Health Professions - A Method of Classification Developed from Common Usage of the Term 'Allied Health' - as Applicable to Rural and Remote Australia. Canberra: Services for Rural and Remote Allied Health (SARRAH).
Øvretveit JA (1985) Medical dominance and the development of professional autonomy in physiotherapy. Sociology of Health and Illness 7:76-93.
Øvretveit JA (1992) Therapy Services: Organisation, Management and Autonomy, Chur, Switzerland: Harwood Academic Publishers.
Øvretveit JA (1994) Physiotherapy service contracts and 'business autonomy'. Physiotherapy 80:372-376.
Packwood T, Keen J and Buxton M (1991) Hospitals in Transition: The Resource Management Experiment, Buckingham, UK: Open University Press.
Public Service Association (1990) Allied Health Departments in Public Hospitals, Sydney: Public Service Association.
Sackmann SA (1992) Cultures and subcultures: An analysis of organizational knowledge. Administrative Science Quarterly 37:140-161.
Strauss A, Schatzman L, Ehrlich D, Bucher R and Sabshin M (1963) The Hospital and its Negotiated Order. In E Freidson (ed) The Modern Hospital. London: The Free Press of Glencoe.
Stacey M (1988) Social organization of health care and the division of paid health labour. In M Stacey (ed) The Sociology of Health and Healing. London: Unwin and Hyman, pp.177-193.
Trice, H M (1993) Occupational Subcultures in the Workplace, No 26 in Cornell Studies in Industrial and Labor Relations, Ithaca: ILR Press.
Van Maanen J and Barley SR (1984) Occupational communities: Culture and control in organizations. In BM Staw and LL Cummings (eds) Research in Organizational Behaviour. Greenwich, CT: JAI Press, pp.287-365.
Willis E (1989) Medical Dominance: The Division of Labour in Australian Health Care 2nd edn, Sydney: Allen and Unwin.
Witz A (1994) The challenge of nursing. In J Gabe, D Kelleher and G Williams (eds) Challenging Medicine. London: Routledge, pp.23-45.
Wong WP, Galley P and Sheehan M (1994) Changes in medical referrals to an outpatient physiotherapy department. Australian Physiotherapy 40:9-14.
eContent Home