Archives
Beyond Decline
Consumerism, managerialism and the need for a new medical professionalism
Willem Tousijn
Department of Social Sciences, University of Torino, Italy
Abstract
In the health care occupational sector powerful social changes have been involved in challenging two of its core features: the centrality of professionalism and medical dominance.
This article proposes that factors internal to the health care system, such as health care reforms, can be explained by factors associated with large-scale social developments such as neo-liberalism and post-modernity. The most significant of these have been consumerism and managerialism. The impact of both is assessed by relying on theoretical insights and empirical evidence from recent studies in several countries.
Finally, the need for a new medical professionalism will be considered as an adaptive response to the challenges coming from social change.
Keywords
sociology, medical profession, consumerism, managerialism, medical dominance, professionalism
References
Aasland OG (2001) The physician role in transition: is Hippocrates sick? Social Science & Medicine 52: 171-173.
Abbott A (1988) The System of Professions. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press.
Allsop J and Mulcahy L (1998) Maintaining professional identity: doctors' responses to complaints. Sociology of Health & Illness 20: 802-824.
Allsop J, Jones K and Baggott R (2002) Professional associations and their engagement with health consumer groups in the UK. Paper presented to the ISA World Conference, Brisbane
Arliaud M and Robelet M (2000) Réformes du système de santé et devenir du « corps medical. Sociologie du Travail 42(1): 91-112
Bortolami S (2002) Soddisfazione e insoddisfazione: le prospettive della qualità percepita. In S Scanagatta (a cura di) Cittadinanza e salute. La forza dell'opinione del cittadino nella sanità veneta. Milano: Franco Angeli
Britten N (2001) Prescribing and the defence of clinical autonomy. Sociology of Health & Illness 23(4): 478-496.
Broadbent J, Dietrich M and Roberts J (1997) The End of the Professions? London: Routledge.
Calnan M and Gabe J (2001) From consumerism to partnership? Britain's NHS at the turn of the century. International Journal of Health Services 31: 119-131.
Calnan M and Williams S (1995) Challenges to professional autonomy in the United Kingdom? The perceptions of general practitioners. International Journal of Health Services 25: 219-241.
Cipolla C, Corposanto C and Tousijn W (a cura di) I medici di medicina generale in Italia. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Coburn D (1992) Freidson then and now: An 'internalist' critique of Freidson's past and present views of the medical profession. International Journal of Health Services 22(3): 497-512.
Coburn D and Willis E (2000) The medical profession: Knowledge, power, and autonomy. In GL Albrecht, R Fitzpatrick and S Scrimshaw (eds) Handbook of Social Studies in Health and Medicine. London: Sage.
Cohen L and Musson G (2000) Entrepreneurial identities: Reflections from two case studies. Organization 7(1): 31-48.
Courpasson D (2000) Managerial strategies of domination. Power in soft bureaucracies. Organization Studies 21(1): 141-161.
Crilly T and Le Grand J (2004) The motivation and behaviour of hospital Trust. Social Science & Medicine 58: 1809-1823.
Davies C (1996) A new vision of professionalisms. Nursing Times 92.
Doolin B (2002) Enterprise discourse, professional identity and the organizational control of hospitals clinicians. Organization Studies 23(3): 369-381.
Engel GI (1977) The need for a new medical model. A challenge for medicine. Science 4286: 129-138.
Exworthy M, Wilkinson EK, McColl A, Moore M, Roderick P, Smith H and Gabbay J (2003) The role of performance indicators in changing the autonomy of the general practice profession in the UK. Social Science & Medicine 56(7): 1493-1504.
Flynn R (2002) Clinical governance and governmentality. Health, Risk & Society 4(2): 155-173.
Fournier V (2000) Boundary work and the (un)making of the professions. In N Malin (ed) Professionalism, Boundaries and the Workplace. London: Routledge.
Fox RC (2000) Medical uncertainty revisited. In GL Albrecht, R Fitzpatrick and S Scrimshaw (eds) Handbook of Social Studies in Health and Medicine. London: Sage.
Freidson E (1970a) Professional Dominance. New York: Atherton.
Freidson E (1970b) Profession of Medicine. New York: Dodd & Mead.
Freidson E (1985) The reorganization of the medical profession. Medical Care Review 42.
Freidson E (1986) The medical profession in transition. In LH Aiken and D Mechanic (eds) Applications of Social Science to Clinical Medicine and Health Policy. Rutgers University Press.
Freidson E (2001) Professionalism. The third logic. Oxford: Polity Press.
Gamba M (2006) Il consumerismo in sanità: la gestione dei reclami in un'ASL piemontese. Dissertation, University of Torino.
Germov J (2005) Managerialism in the Australian public health sector: towards the hyper-rationalisation of professional bureaucracies. Sociology of Health & Illness 27(6): 738-758.
Giarelli G (2003) Il malessere della medicina, Milano: Franco Angeli.
Giddens A (1990) The Consequences of Modernity, Cambridge: Polity Press.
Giorgino V (2003) Infermieristica e paesaggi del prendersi cura. Salute e Società 2(1): 15-38.
Halpern SA (1990) Medicalization as professional process: Post-war trends in pediatrics. Journal of Health and Social Behaviour 31: 28-42.
Halpern SA (1992) Dynamics of professional control: Internal coalitions and cross professional boundaries. American Journal of Sociology 97(4): 994-1021.
Hanlon G (1999) Lawyers, the State and the Market. Professionalism Revisited. London: Macmillan.
Kendall L and Lissauer R (2003) The Future Health Worker. London: Institute for Public Policy Research.
Kitchener M (1999) All fur coats and no knickers. Contemporary organizational change in UK hospitals. In D Brock, M Powell and CR Hinings (eds) Restructuring the Professional Organization. Accounting, Health Care and Law. London: Routledge.
Kitchener M, Caronna CA and Shortell SM (2005) From the doctor's shop to the iron cage? Evolving modes of physician control in US health systems. Social Science & Medicine 60: 1311-1322.
Kuhlmann E (2004) Knowledge and power in the era of consumerism. Negotiations on professionalism in health care. Paper presented to ISA RC52 Conference, Versailles.
Larson M (1977) The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological Analysis. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Lee RG and Garvin T (2003) Moving from information transfer to information exchange. Social Science & Medicine 56: 449-464.
Lupton D (1997) Consumerism, reflexivity and the medical encounter. Social Science & Medicine 45(3): 373-381.
Manghi S (2005) Il medico, il paziente e l'altro. Milano: Franco Angeli.
Marjoribanks T and Lewis JM (2003) Reform and autonomy: perceptions of the Australian general practice community. Social Science & Medicine 56: 2229-2239.
McKinlay JB and Stoeckle J (1988) Corporatisation and the social transformation of doctoring. International Journal of Health Services 18(2): 191-205.
Mechanic D (2000) Managed care and the imperative for a new professional ethic. Health Affairs 19(5): 100-111.
Mechanic D (2001) The managed care backlash: perceptions and rhetoric in health care policy and the potential for health care reform. The Milbank Quarterly 79(1): 35-54.
Moran M (1999) Governing the health care state. A comparative study of the UK, the US and Germany. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
Saks M (2005) Professions and the Public Interest. London: Routledge.
Salmon P and Hall GM (2003) Patient empowerment and control: a psychological discourse in the service of medicine. Social Science & Medicine 57: 1969-1980.
Salter B (2003) Patients and doctors: reformulating the UK health policy community? Social Science & Medicine 57: 927-936.
Scott WR (1982) Managing professional work: three models of control for health organizations. Health Services Research 17: 213-240.
Sheaff R, Rogers A, Pickard S, Marshall M, Campbell S, Sibbald B, Halliwell S and Roland M. A subtle governance: soft medical leadership in English primary care. Sociology of Health & Illness 25(5): 408-428.
Southon G and Braithwaite J (1998) The end of professionalism? Social Science & Medicine 46: 23-28.
Stacey M (1988) The Sociology of Health and Healing. London: Routledge & Kegan.
Stevens R (2001) Public roles for the medical profession in the United States: beyond theories of decline and fall. The Milbank Quarterly 79(3).
Stevenson FA, Britten N, Barry CA, Bradley CP and Barber N. Self-treatment and its discussion in medical consultations: how is medical pluralism managed in practice? Social Science & Medicine 57: 513-527.
Sullivan M (2003) The new subjective medicine: taking the patient's point of view on health care and health. Social Science & Medicine 56: 1595-1604.
Tousijn W (1994) Il sistema delle occupazioni sanitarie: processi di professionalizzazione e dominanza medica. Polis 8(2): 203-222.
Tousijn W (2002) Medical dominance in Italy: a partial decline. Social Science and Medicine 55: 733-741.
Zetka JR (2001) Occupational Divisions of Labor and Their Technology Politics. The Case of Surgical Scopes and Gastrointestinal Medicine. Social Forces 79(4): 1495-1520.
eContent Home