'Thoroughly modern mothers': Maternal aspirations and declining mortality on Lihir Island, Papua New Guinea
Martha Macintyre
Centre for the Study of Health and Society, School of Population Health, University of Melbourne, VIC
PP: 043 - 053
Abstract
Attempts to improve overall rates of maternal and child survival and health in Pacific societies have often sought explanation in the traditional ideas and cultural practices that were assumed to discourage women from embracing introduced, modern medical services.
Based on ethnographic fieldwork and data collected in the context of social monitoring of the impacts of a mining project on Lihir Island, this paper describes a case in which women have rapidly adopted Western medical treatments and hospital birth, and experienced dramatic health benefits as a consequence. Ease of access, quality and reliability of service provision were considered most important influences affecting women's decisions, with cultural beliefs rarely invoked as reasons for giving birth in a village.
It argues that, in spite of sharing many of the ideas and practices that have elsewhere been considered impediments to acceptance of hospital care, Lihirian women have embraced the new system as epitomising their progression to modernity.
Keywords
tradition; modernity; childbirth; Papua New Guinea
References
Brouwer E, Harris BM and Tanaka S (eds) (1998) Gender analysis in Papua New Guinea, Washington DC: The World Bank.
Brown P and Buchbinder G (eds) (1976) Male and female in the New Guinea Highlands, Washington DC: American Anthropological Association.
Buckley T and Gottlieb A (eds) (1988) Blood magic: The anthropology of menstruation, London: University of California Press.
Davis-Floyd R (1996) The technocratic body and the organic body: Hegemony and heresy in women's birth choices, pp.123-166, in Carolyn F Sargent and CF Brettell (eds) Gender and health: An international perspective, Upper Saddle River NJ: Prentice Hall.
Davis-Floyd R and Sargent CF (1997) Childbirth and authoritative knowledge: Cross-cultural perspectives, Berkeley and London: University of California Press.
Denoon D (1989) Public health in Papua New Guinea: Medical possibility and social constraint, 1884-1984, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dickson R (1981) Lihir District Maternal Health Survey Report, Kavieng: New Ireland Provincial Government Department of Health.
Douglas M (1966) Purity and danger: An analysis of the concepts of pollution and taboo, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Filer C and Jackson R (1989) The social and economic impact of a gold mine in Lihir: Revised and expanded, Unpublished report to the Lihir Liaison Committee: Port Moresby.
Fiti-Sinclair R (2002) Childbirth in Papua New Guinea villages and in Port Moresby General Hospital, in Vicki Lukere and Margaret Jolly (eds) (2002) Birthing in the Pacific: Beyond tradition and modernity, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press: 56-78
Frankel S (1981) The Huli response to illness, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Frankel S and Gilbert L (eds) (1989) A continuing trial of treatment: Medical pluralism in Papua New Guinea, Boston: Kluwer.
Hemer S (2001) A malmalien e makil: Person, emotion and relations in Lihir, PhD thesis, University of Melbourne.
Hemer S (2002) Maternal health in the Lihir Islands: A review, Unpublished report prepared for Lihir Management Company Community Relations Section.
Hughes H (2003) Aid has failed the Pacific, Paper no.33, The Centre for Independent Studies, www.cis.org.au/issueanalysis/ia33/ia33.htm
Iangalio R (1987) Programs and activities of the Family Planning Association of Papua New Guinea, in Susan Stratigos and Philip Hughes (eds) The ethics of development: Justice and the distribution of healthcare, Port Moresby: University of Papua New Guinea: 88-93.
Jenkins C (1992) Medical anthropology in Papua New Guinea: A challenge, in Robert D Attenborough and Michael Alpers (eds) Human biology in Papua New Guinea: The small cosmos, Oxford: Clarendon Press: 387.
Jolly M (2002) Introduction: Birthing beyond the confinements of tradition and modernity, in Vicki Lukere and Margaret Jolly (eds) (2002) Birthing in the Pacific: Beyond tradition and modernity, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press: 1-31.
Jordan B (1978) Birth in four cultures: A cross-cultural investigation of childbirth in Yucatan, Holland, Sweden and the United States, Montreal: Eden Press.
Kitzinger S (1972) The experience of childbirth, London: Penguin.
Kowal E (2000) Children, choice and change: The use of Western contraception on the Lihir Islands, Papua New Guinea, BA Hons.Thesis, University of Melbourne.
Lewis G (2000) A failure of treatment, Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Lukere V and Jolly M (eds) (2002) Birthing in the Pacific: Beyond tradition and modernity, Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press.
Macintyre M (2002) Women and mining projects in Papua New Guinea: Problems of consultation, representation and women's rights, in Ingrid Macdonald and Claire Rowland (eds) Tunnel vision: Women mining and communities. Melbourne: Oxfam-Community Aid Abroad: 26-29.
Macintyre M and Foale S (2003) Global imperatives and local desires: Competing economic and environmental interests in Melanesian communities, in V Lockwood (ed) Pacific Island societies in a global world. New York: Prentice Hall: 149- 164.
Macintyre M (in press) Matrilineal structures and patriarchal values, in Margaret Jolly and Vicki Lukere (eds) Women's health in the Pacific, Honolulu: University of Hawaii.
Macintyre M (2004) Petztorme women: Responding to change on Lihir, Papua New Guinea, in Bronwen Douglas (ed) Oceania, special volume 'Women's groups and everyday modernity in Melanesia', Sydney: Oceania Publications: 225-248.
Macintyre M (2004a) Indigenous healing, in T Robson (ed.) Complementary medicine, Sydney: Allen & Unwin: 33-47.
McKinnon E (2002) The environmental impacts of waste disposal at Lihir Gold Mine, Papua New Guinea, Journal of Rural and Remote Environmental Health 1(2): 40-50.
Manderson L (1992) Maternal and child health in colonial Malaya, in Valerie Fildes, Lara Marks and Hilary Marland (eds) Women and children first: International maternal and infant welfare, London: Routledge: 154-177.
Mola G and Aitken I (1989) Maternal death in Papua New Guinea, Papua New Guinea Medical Journal 32: 27-31.
MPI (no date) Submarine tailings disposal (STD), Mineral Policy Institute, www.nic.net.au/mpi/std/
NSRRT (National Sex and Reproduction Research Team) and Jenkins C (1994) National study of sexual and reproductive knowledge and behaviour in Papua New Guinea, Goroka: Papua New Guinea Institute of Medical Research.
National Statistics Office (1998) Papua New Guinea health and demographic survey, 1996: Port Moresby.
Sinclair RS (1987) Anthropologists and understanding the relationship between traditional and Western medicine in Papua New Guinea, in Susan Stratigos and Philip Hughes (eds) The ethics of development: Justice and the distribution of healthcare, Port Moresby: University of Papua New Guinea: 44-65.
Rice PL and Manderson L (eds) (1996) Maternity and reproductive health in Asian societies, Amsterdam: Harwood Academic Publishers.
Taufa T (1989) The impact of the Ok Tedi mining project on the Wopkaimin society, in Susan Stratigos and Phillip Hughes (eds) The ethics of development: Justice and the distribution of health care, Port Moresby: University of Papua New Guinea: 79-87.
Taufa T, Day G and Mea V (1991) Base-line health survey of Lihir Islanders, Unpublished Report: University of PNG.
UNDP (1999) Pacific human development report 1999: Creating opportunities, Suva, Fiji: United Nations Development Program.
UNFPA (1997) United Nations population fund in Papua New Guinea, Port Moresby: UNFPA PNG Field Office.
WHO (World Health Organization) (1995) Safe motherhood: Newsletter of worldwide activity in maternal health, Geneva: World Health Organisation.
eContent Home
