Troublesome breasts: Older women living in the liminal state of being 'at risk' of breast cancer
Yoni Luxford
School of Health, Faculty of the Professions, University of New England, Armidale NSW
PP: 146 - 154
Abstract
Deep in her breast lives the silent wound.
(Anon.)
It is almost unthinkable to consider any condition of the breast without simultaneously evoking the dread of breast cancer. The ways in which women's experience of 'benign breast disease' and 'risk' disrupt the notion of a previously predictable and familiar relationship with the self/body form the subject of this paper. A discursive analysis of both terms is followed by a case study which illustrates and analyses the subject positions one woman takes up as she lives the everyday/every night embodiment of troublesome breasts.
Troublesome breasts are experienced as enduring, and simultaneously immediate, embodied reminders of uncertainty. A diagnosis of 'benign breast disease' may offer a sense of relief and reassurance for women because it is not, in this moment, breast cancer. But it is a slippery and difficult position to hold because of the embodied fear that it may, at any time, become cancer. Thus closure is always partial. Women's very engagement with ongoing surveillance ensures that the body remembers; and the ongoing bodily production of memory reaches beyond any physical symptom or particular encounter with the clinic.
Keywords
benign breast disease; breast cancer; older women; risk; clinic; surveillance
References
Collins (2001) The New Collins Concise English Dictionary, Sydney.
Douglas M (1978) Purity and danger: An analysis of concepts of pollution and taboo, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul.
Foucault M (1973) The birth of the clinic: The archeology of medical perception, London: Tavistock.
Foucault M (1977) Discipline and punish London: Tavistock
Fox N (1999) Postmodern reflections on 'risk', 'hazards' and life choices' in Deborah Lupton (ed) Risk and sociological theory: New directions and perspectives, Cambridge University Press: 12-34.
Gigerenzer G (2002) Reckoning with risk: Learning to live with uncertainty, London: Penguin Press.
Gifford S (1986) The Meaning of lumps: a case study of the ambiguity of risk, in CR Janes, R Stall, and SM Gifford (eds) Anthropology and epidemiology: Interdisciplinary approaches to the study of health and disease, Boston: Reidel: 213-246.
Love S (2000) with Karen Lindsey Dr Susan Love's Breast Book 3rd edn, Reading: Addison-Wesley.
Lupton D (1994) Femininity, responsibility, and the technological imperative: Discourses on breast cancer in the Australian press, International Journal of Health Services 24(1): 73-89.
Lupton D (1995) The imperative of health: Public health and the regulated body, London: Sage.
Lupton D (1999) (ed.) Risk and sociological theory: New directions and perspectives, Cambridge University Press.
Luxford Y (1999) Breasts talk back: A discursive analysis of older women's breast health narratives, unpublished PhD thesis, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia.
National Breast Cancer Centre (1999) Summary of risk factors for breast cancer, http://www.nbcc.org.au/pages/info/resource/nbccpubs/risksumm/contents.htm (accessed 10/05/2003).
National Breast Cancer Centre (2003) Breast changes, http://www.nbcc.org.au/pages/info/resource/nbccpubs/brchanges/contents.htm (accessed 10/05/2003).
National Health and Medical Research Council (1995) Clinical practice guidelines for the management of early breast cancer, Sydney: NHMRC.
Sedgwick EK (1993) Tendencies, Durham: Duke University Press.
Simpson C (2000) Controversies in breast cancer prevention: The discourse of risk, in Laura Potts (ed) Ideologies of breast cancer: Feminist perspectives, London: MacMillan Press: 131-152.
The Medical Dictionary (2003) http://www.medterms.com/script/main/art.asp?articlekey=2449 (accessed 18/08/2003).
eContent Home
