Archives
Abortion
The shift in stigmatisation from those seeking abortion to those providing it
Margie Ripper
Department of Social Inquiry, University of Adelaide, Adelaide Australia
Abstract
There have been important shifts in the characterisation of abortion and those who provide it over the last thirty years in Australia.
This paper distinguishes three periods that represent these shifts. The most recent period reveals a renewed stigmatisation of abortion-providing doctors. Two intersecting factors are shown to have contributed to this.
On the one hand those who oppose abortion have used key concepts from the women's health agenda, public health discourse and consumerist rhetoric to position themselves as advocates for women's health and to stigmatise and discredit doctors who perform abortions.
On the other hand some feminist commentators have moved away from framing abortion as a 'health issue' and embraced elements of a discourse of ethics which had previously been the province of anti-abortion commentators. Within this contextual framework I illustrate the increased stigmatisation of doctors who perform abortion.
Keywords
abortion, ethics, feminism, stigma, women's health
References
Australian Capital Territory (1998) Hansard of the Legislative Assembly of the Australian Capital Territory. Canberra.
Baird B (1990) 'I had one too...': an oral history of abortion in South Australia before 1970, Adelaide: The Flinders University of South Australia.
Cannold L (1998) The abortion myth: abortion and the changing future of women, St Leonards NSW: Allen & Unwin.
Cannold L (2001) ‘Women hurt by abortion': in search of a practical, feminist and politically effective approach to information provision and options counselling. In Abortion-politics, access and challenges, Proceedings of the Biennial Conference of the Abortion Providers Federation of Australia, Adelaide Nov 2001. Adelaide: Pregnancy Advisory Centre: 77-90.
Davies J-A (1999) Airport quiz for abortion doctor, The Age 13/11/1999: 1.
Davies J-A (2000) Threat of ban angers abortion doctor, The Age 26/10/1/2000: 3.
Duvnjak A (2001) Abortion, feminism and the 'new' politics of morality, Politics, Action Renewal: Proceedings of the 4th National Women's Health Conference, Strathfieldsaye VIC: Australian Women's Health Network: 341-348.
Greer G (1999) The Whole Woman, London, Sydney: Doubleday.
Klein R (ed) (1989) Infertility; Women speak of their experiences of reproductive medicine, London: Pandora Press.
National Health and Medical Research Council (1996) An Information Paper on Termination of Pregnancy in Australia, Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service.
North L (2001) Myths, morals and Makeovers: the print media's portrayal of abortion. In Abortion-Politics, Access and Challenges, Proceedings of the Biennial Conference of the Abortion Providers Federation of Australia. Adelaide Nov 2001, Adelaide: Pregnancy Advisory Centre: 18-24.
Reist MT (2000) Giving sorrow words: women's stories of grief after abortion Potts Point NSW: Duffy & Snellgrove.
Ripper M and Ryan L (1998) The role of the 'withdrawal method' in the control of abortion, Australian Feminist Studies 13(28): 313-321.
Rowland R (1992) Living laboratories: women and reproductive technologies, Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
Rowland Hogue B, Boardman L, Stotland N and Peipet J (1999) Answering questions about long term outcomes. In M Paul, E Steve Lichtenberg, L Borgatta, D Grimes and P Srubblefield (eds) A clinician's guide to medical and surgical abortion, Philadelphia: Churchill Livingstone: 217-218.
Ryan L, Ripper M and Buttfield B (1994) We women decide: women's experience of seeking abortion in Queensland, South Australia and Tasmania 1985-1992, Adelaide: The Flinders University of South Australia. Western Australia (1998) Hansard.
Wolf N (1995) Our bodies, our souls: rethinking pro-choice rhetoric, The New Republic 213(16): 26-33.
eContent Home